Strateal

Pink noise for sleep.What the studies actually tested.

Pink noise has a reputation as the sleep noise with science behind it. Some of that is fair and some is not. The studies people point to tested something quite different from playing pink noise through a speaker all night.

Pink noise has equal power in every octave, so it sounds fuller and softer than white noise. The studies behind its reputation played short bursts of it, timed to brain waves during deep sleep in a lab, not steady noise all night. For ordinary use it has not been shown to work better than other sounds, but many people find it easier to listen to than white noise.

What pink noise is

Pink noise carries the same power in every octave, so low and high pitches get an equal share. It sounds fuller than white noise and less hissy, close to steady rain or wind in leaves. White noise, by contrast, has the same power at every single frequency, and because each higher octave holds twice as many frequencies, it sounds bright. Pink noise, measured shows the five versions in Hush.

What the studies tested

The best-known results come from sleep labs. In a 2013 study in Neuron, researchers recorded sleepers' brain activity and, during deep sleep, played short bursts of pink noise timed to the peaks of their slow brain waves. Those waves grew stronger, and the sleepers remembered more of a list of word pairs the next morning.

Later work repeated the approach, including a 2017 study in older adults that found stronger slow waves and better recall in those whose waves responded most. Every one of these studies used the same ingredients: EEG, a computer listening to the brain, and sounds lasting a fraction of a second, switched on and off in step with it.

A speaker playing pink noise all night does none of that. The studies are real and interesting, but they are evidence for timed bursts, not for steady pink noise.

What is known about steady noise

For steady noise, the kind a sound app or machine plays, the picture is thinner. A 2021 systematic review in Sleep Medicine Reviews collected studies of continuous noise for sleep and rated the evidence as very low certainty. Some found benefits, some found none, and many were small or poorly controlled.

So pink noise has not been shown to beat other sounds in ordinary use. Its real advantage is simpler: it is less sharp than white noise, which makes it easier to leave on.

Pink noise benefits: claims and evidence

The benefits listed for pink noise mix what labs found with what they did not test:

ClaimWhat research shows
Deeper sleepTimed bursts in labs strengthened slow brain waves. Not shown for steady pink noise from a speaker.
Better memorySmall lab studies with timed bursts found better overnight recall of word pairs. Not shown for steady noise.
Falling asleep fasterNot established. Evidence for steady noise in general is very low certainty.
Covering other noiseTrue of any steady sound: a constant background makes sudden noises stand out less. Pink noise is not special here.

White noise vs pink noise for sleep

Between 2 and 12 kHz, Velvet noise stays about level, close to level, while White static rises 1.6 dB per octave. White noise has proportionally more energy at the top, which you hear as hiss. Pink noise keeps the balance even, so no part of the sound pushes forward.

Neither has been shown to work better. White noise has more energy where speech sits, so it covers voices a little more at the same volume; pink noise is gentler to listen to. If you are unsure, start with pink.

0-10-20-30-4022.5345681012
Velvet noise −0.2 dB per octaveWhite static +1.6 dB per octave
Band by band, in numbers
Level in each band, in dB relative to each sound's overall level
BandVelvet noiseWhite staticDifference
2 kHz−8.6 dB−7.8 dB+0.8 dB
2.5 kHz−8.8 dB−7.2 dB+1.6 dB
3 kHz−8.9 dB−6.6 dB+2.3 dB
4 kHz−8.8 dB−5.7 dB+3.1 dB
5 kHz−8.6 dB−4.8 dB+3.8 dB
6 kHz−8.4 dB−4.2 dB+4.2 dB
8 kHz−8.4 dB−3.5 dB+4.9 dB
10 kHz−9.0 dB−3.8 dB+5.2 dB
12 kHz−10.0 dB−4.6 dB+5.4 dB

Pink noise vs brown noise

Brown noise goes further in the same direction: its power falls faster as pitch rises, so it is deeper still. In Hush, Deep brown falls 3.4 dB per octave between 2 and 12 kHz. If pink noise sounds too bright, brown is the next step down; is brown noise good for sleep? covers it.

How to try pink noise

A fair trial takes a few nights:

  1. Keep it quiet, just enough to soften the room.
  2. Place the speaker across the room, not beside your head.
  3. Decide how it ends: a sleep timer with a fade, or play until morning if you wake when sound stops.
  4. Give it three or four nights before judging it.
  5. If it feels too bright, try brown noise; if too dull, try white.

Sources

Sounds in this article

  • Velvet noiseSoft and balancedTilt −0.2 dBper octaveOne steady soundFree
  • Warm staticRounded and gentleTilt −4.3 dBper octaveOne steady soundHush Plus
  • Rose staticSmooth and warmTilt −3.8 dBper octaveOne steady soundHush Plus
  • Soft staticMuted and diffuseTilt −4.9 dBper octaveOne steady soundHush Plus

Related guides

  1. Green noise for sleep. What it is, and how to try it.Green noise has no technical definition, yet many people play it at night. What it means, how it compares with white, pink and brown noise, and how to try it.
  2. What colour noise is best for sleep?White, pink, brown or green noise for sleep? No colour is best for everyone. How to choose by what keeps you awake, with each colour measured.
  3. Is brown noise good for sleep?Brown noise is the deepest noise colour and a popular sleep sound. What it is, what research does and does not show, and how to use it at night.
  4. Brown noise for tinnitus.Many people with tinnitus try brown noise. What is known about background sound and ringing, how brown noise differs, and how to try it safely.

Questions

Does pink noise improve deep sleep?

Lab studies found that short bursts of pink noise, timed to slow brain waves, strengthened those waves. That has not been shown for steady pink noise played all night, which is how most people use it.

Is pink noise better than white noise for sleep?

Neither has been shown to work better in ordinary use. Pink noise sounds softer and less hissy, so many people find it easier to listen to at night.

What is pink noise for sleep?

A steady noise with equal power in every octave, played at a low volume as a background. It sounds like steady rain and is softer than white noise.

Can I play pink noise all night?

Yes, at a low volume with the speaker away from your head. Velvet noise, Hush's pink noise, is free.

Ask your own question at info@strateal.com

Hear them in Hush.Six sounds are free.